Watching traffic on the opensuse-factory mailing list has brought home one of the maxims of Linuxdom that has been true for over a decade: People run Linux on some really old crap. And really, it makes sense. How much hardware do you really need for a router/firewall between your home network and the internet? Shoving packets is not a high-test application if you only have two interfaces. Death and fundamental hardware speed-limits are what kills these beasts off.
This is one feature that Linux shares with NetWare. Because NetWare gets run on some really old crap too, since it just works, and you don't need a lot of hardware for a file-server for only 500 people. Once you get over a 1000 or very large data-sets the problem gets more interesting, but for general office-style documents... you don't need much. This is/was one of the attractions for NetWare, you need not much hardware and it runs for years.
On the factory mailing list people have been lamenting recent changes in the kernel and entire environment that has been somewhat deleterious for really old crap boxes. The debate goes back and forth, but at the end of the day the fact remains that a lot of people throw Linux on hardware they'd otherwise dispose of for being too old. And until recently, it has just worked.
However, the diaspora of hardware over the last 15 years has caught up to Linux. Supporting everything sold in the last 15 years requires a HELL of a lot of drivers. And not only that, but really old drivers need to be revised to keep up with changes in the kernel, and that requires active maintainers with that ancient hardware around for testing. These requirements mean that more and more of these really old, or moderately old but niche, drivers are drifting into abandonware-land. Linux as an ecosystem just can't keep up anymore. The Linux community decries Windows for its obsession with 'backwards compatibility' and how that stifles innovation. And yet they have a 12 year old PII box under the desk happily pushing packets.
NetWare didn't have this problem, even though it's been around longer. The driver interfaces in the NetWare kernel changed a very few times over the last 20 years (such as the DRV to HAM conversion during the NetWare 4.x era, and the introduction of SMP later on) which allowed really old drivers to continue working without revision for a really long time. This is how a 1998 vintage server could be running in 2007, and running well.
However, Linux is not NetWare. NetWare is a special purpose operating system, no matter what Novell tried in the late 90's to make it a general purpose one (NetWare + Apache + MySQL + PHP = a LAMP server that is far more vulnerable to runaway thread based DoS). Linux is a general purpose operating system. This key difference between the two means that Linux got exposed to a lot more weird hardware than NetWare ever did. SCSI attached scanners made no sense on NetWare, but they did on Linux 10 years ago. Putting any kind of high-test graphics card into a NetWare server is a complete waste, but on Linux it'll give you those awesome wibbly-windows.
There comes a time when an open source project has to cut away the old stuff. Figuring this out is hard, especially when the really old crap is running under desks or in closets entirely forgotten. It is for this reason that Smolt was born. To create a database of hardware that is running Linux, as a way to figure out driver development priorities. Both in creating new, missing drivers, and keeping up old but still frequently used drivers.
If you're running a Pentium 2-233 machine as your network's NTP server, you need to let the Linux community know about it so your platform maintains supportability. It is no longer good enough to assume that if it worked in Linux once, it'll always work in Linux.
This is one feature that Linux shares with NetWare. Because NetWare gets run on some really old crap too, since it just works, and you don't need a lot of hardware for a file-server for only 500 people. Once you get over a 1000 or very large data-sets the problem gets more interesting, but for general office-style documents... you don't need much. This is/was one of the attractions for NetWare, you need not much hardware and it runs for years.
On the factory mailing list people have been lamenting recent changes in the kernel and entire environment that has been somewhat deleterious for really old crap boxes. The debate goes back and forth, but at the end of the day the fact remains that a lot of people throw Linux on hardware they'd otherwise dispose of for being too old. And until recently, it has just worked.
However, the diaspora of hardware over the last 15 years has caught up to Linux. Supporting everything sold in the last 15 years requires a HELL of a lot of drivers. And not only that, but really old drivers need to be revised to keep up with changes in the kernel, and that requires active maintainers with that ancient hardware around for testing. These requirements mean that more and more of these really old, or moderately old but niche, drivers are drifting into abandonware-land. Linux as an ecosystem just can't keep up anymore. The Linux community decries Windows for its obsession with 'backwards compatibility' and how that stifles innovation. And yet they have a 12 year old PII box under the desk happily pushing packets.
NetWare didn't have this problem, even though it's been around longer. The driver interfaces in the NetWare kernel changed a very few times over the last 20 years (such as the DRV to HAM conversion during the NetWare 4.x era, and the introduction of SMP later on) which allowed really old drivers to continue working without revision for a really long time. This is how a 1998 vintage server could be running in 2007, and running well.
However, Linux is not NetWare. NetWare is a special purpose operating system, no matter what Novell tried in the late 90's to make it a general purpose one (NetWare + Apache + MySQL + PHP = a LAMP server that is far more vulnerable to runaway thread based DoS). Linux is a general purpose operating system. This key difference between the two means that Linux got exposed to a lot more weird hardware than NetWare ever did. SCSI attached scanners made no sense on NetWare, but they did on Linux 10 years ago. Putting any kind of high-test graphics card into a NetWare server is a complete waste, but on Linux it'll give you those awesome wibbly-windows.
There comes a time when an open source project has to cut away the old stuff. Figuring this out is hard, especially when the really old crap is running under desks or in closets entirely forgotten. It is for this reason that Smolt was born. To create a database of hardware that is running Linux, as a way to figure out driver development priorities. Both in creating new, missing drivers, and keeping up old but still frequently used drivers.
If you're running a Pentium 2-233 machine as your network's NTP server, you need to let the Linux community know about it so your platform maintains supportability. It is no longer good enough to assume that if it worked in Linux once, it'll always work in Linux.